Which one is better in fifa 12,Defending or Legacy Defending??

[Kork]

I have played both the game fifa 11 as well as fifa 12 by tactical defending and with the old legacy defending so just wanted to know from you all that which is better tactical defending or the legacy defending? which from these you have found interesting and why?

[Ceesar]

Even i have played both of them and what i have found is that "Tactical Defending" is much more interesting because it is likely to be challenging and it really needs some good skills to go on where as Legacy Defending appears as if it is meant for those who just want to enjoy this game with all the assisted controls rather than going tough and checking their skills.I personally don't find any kind of simulation factor by just holding the A button and keep tackling it automatically.I just wish if the Legacy Defending is thrown out from the online ones.

[Illinois]

Even i find the tactical defending better i like the revolution by FIFA it is interestingly a massive hit it helps us to learn from the scratch i just like all the skills like the very basic shooting and defending we just keep on learning every skills in the tactical defending rather than just playing the automatic skills by just pressing letters.Tactical Defending is just not the best improvement but it makes you feel that you are starting a new game even though you have played the same in fifa 11 so my vote goes for tactical defending.

[Kickapoo]

My views are a bit different i think that tactical defending is perfect when you are playing it offline but when you try to play it online there game gets much tougher then one could think about it.I have also made a script in AutoHotkey simulating tackle with latency of 100 mms and i have found that it is likely to be impossible to grab the ball from the opponent you just don't get any chance and you are just left with trying and stopping goals of opponents,here I at least the player should some steps just before making the tackle but if its about testing skills then i will say if the game is tough you have to get tougher.

[Cruzz]

I mostly like tactical defending because it just provide you some good skills in order to defend and feel the realism rather than just thinking about goalling any how using the automatic buttons.Tactical defending is for those who like to play world class tough levels and want to experience the new challenges in the defending and who just Try to enjoy every challenges such as controlling the ball,tackling it and passing it around,grabbing the ball from the opponents as well as stopping opponents passes.In short tactical defending is for hardcore gamers not for those who play it just for fun.

[Odalis]

I don't find it worth to compare tactical defending with the old legacy defending,it just sounds like comparing masters with their students it don't make any sense if you just want to try and goal rather to learn some skills and shoot i have also heard that according to some polls 75 percent of people like to go with tactical defending and only 25 percent of people going with the old legacy defending but it really depends in the type of gamer because any hardcore gamer will surely go for tactical defending where as a new learner will definitely go for legacy defending.

[Andrea000]

For me tactical defending is a rocket it will be just exploiting the online gaming experience of fifa ,i think a lot of matches will end with just one goal from a team and none from the other,only the masters will be ruling it i wish that they should make it like PES that keeps all the new standing tackle skills and use the contained ones as well when you find a need for them and lastly even my vote is for tactical defending.